Just when everyone thought they had figured out who was good and who wasn't this season, Week 4 came along and threw them (along with me) for a loop.
Among the seemingly impossible upsets this week were the Broncos losing to the Chiefs, the Redskins being beaten by the Cowboys, and the Bears squeaking by the Eagles.
There are no great teams in the NFL this season.
I can't even pick a Super Bowl favourite anymore. The NFL is wide open and in order to clear my mind for next Sunday, I'm going to go over the teams that I consider to have a shot in hell at making the big game.
AFC
1. Pittsburgh
I still think the Steelers have the best shot at representing the AFC in the Super Bowl this year. Along with Peyton Manning and Jay Cutler, Ben Roethlisberger is the best quarterback in the AFC and makes plays even when he's being harrassed by numerous defensive lineman. The Steelers also have great playmakers at their offensive skill positions and the defence is as good as they come.
The Problem: Their only real weakness is their offensive line, which was exposed big time in a loss to the Eagles last Sunday. I don't know if I've ever seen a quarterback take as much abuse as Roethlisberger did in that game and I'm shocked he hasn't gotten seriously injured yet. If he continues to get smashed, Roethlisberger won't last the season and without him, the Steelers have no hope.
2. Buffalo
I'm a big Bills fan this season and I fully expect them to win the AFC East. Trent Edwards is better than solid and the Bills have solid playmakers on offence. Rookie wide receiver James Hardy should eventually emerge as a top wide receiver and Marshawn Lynch is the AFC's version of Marion Barber running the ball (an absolute killer). The Bills have a very solid defence and have been great on special teams so far, although the injury to Roscoe Parrish will hurt them in that area for a few weeks.
The Problem: Even though the Bills don't have any real weaknesses, I'm not sure if they're good enough in any area to win it all. They are solid from top to bottom, but they don't really have anyone who is exceptional aside from Lynch. If Trent Edwards continues to improve and the Bills can stay healthy, they have a real shot at doing some damage.
3. Indianapolis
Sure, the Colts are 1-2 and look to be down and out, but with the AFC being so wide open, they aren't dead yet. Manning and Co. still have more than 3/4 of a season to put it all together on offence and if that happens, they'll be as dangerous as ever. The more things change, the more they stay the same and Peyton very well could be the last man standing in the AFC this year.
The Problem: Clearly the Colts have not been their old selves so far this year. Peyton Manning is still getting into game shape and the Colts have to make sure they don't fall too far behind. Also, their defence has been abysmal and matters could get much worse with safety Bob Sanders being out for an extended period of time. Indianapolis must solidify their defence at least a little bit if they expect to go all the way.
4. Denver Broncos
Despite losing to the Chiefs this week, I'm still going to say that the Broncos have the best offence in the NFL. Jay Cutler is firing on all cylinders, and Brandon Marshall and Eddie Royal may be the most explosive one-two punch at wide receiver in the entire league. Throw in two solid tight ends (Tony Scheffler and Daniel Graham) and a running back by committee approach that seems to keep everyone fresh, and Denver could score their way to an AFC title.
The Problem: Denver's defence is one of the worst in the league. As proven this Sunday, the Broncos have a shot to lose every game in spite of their exceptional offence.
5. Tennessee Titans
Honestly, I haven't seen much of Tennessee yet this season, but I'm putting them up here because of their 4-0 record. They've beaten a couple of solid teams already this season and look to be the best of the worst in the AFC in this very early 2008 season. Their defence has been great so far and rookie running back Chris Johnson gives their offence some explosiveness they have sorely been lacking in recent years.
The Problem: Kerry Collins? Really??? I just can't see Kerry Collins leading this team deep into the playoffs, but the AFC IS bad so who knows.
NFC
1. Dallas Cowboys
The Redskins played the game of their lives this past Sunday to beat Dallas, but the Cowboys still have to be the favourite to win the Super Bowl this year. Romo is playing like the best quarterback in the NFL and Marion Barber may be the best running back. Although T.O. may think he didn't get the ball enough in the Cowboys first loss, I happen to think he got it too much. The Cowboys didn't run with Barber as much as they should have. Barber's hard-nosed style of running takes a toll on opposing defences and usually tires them out by the fourth quarter.
The Problem: The only real weakness the Cowboys might have is Terrell Owens and his tendency to self-destruct. Tony Romo has blown a few big games in his career, but I don't believe that will continue. Romo is so good and there's no way I can see him retiring with an empty ring finger.
2. Green Bay Packers
The Packers haven't been impressive in their last two games, losing at home to the Cowboys and on the road against the Bucs, but I still see something special when I watch Aaron Rodgers throw the ball. Green Bay was one of the best teams last year with Brett Favre and despite a couple of mistakes in a tough loss to the Bucs this past Sunday, Aaron Rodgers is a much better decision-maker than his predecessor. The Packers offence will get back on track and their defence is still one of the better ones in the NFL, even with the injury to Al Harris.
The Problem: Coach McCarthy has been too conservative with his play calling so far this season. I'd like to see Rodgers throw more on first and second downs. Injuries in the secondary have also hurt the Packers, even though they have great depth at the position.
3. New Orleans Saints
Don't look now, but the Saints defence seems to be improved. Rookie defensive back Tracy Porter has impressed me with his coverage skills and with additions like Jonathan Vilma and Randall Gay, the Saints defence could get better and better as the season goes on. Their offence is as potent as ever and no matter how many of their offensive weapons get hurt, Drew Brees will keep finding open receivers. Reggie Bush has looked rejuvenated this year and when Colston and Shockey come back, it could add a huge midseason boost to a well-coached team.
The Problem: The defence is still shaky, but if they continue to improve, they may end up being one of the NFC's better units before the season is over.
4. New York Giants
The Giants are undefeated so far this season and still have the same offence that led them to a Super Bowl last year. Justin Tuck has turned into a superstar and the whole defence has done an impressive job overcoming the losses of Michael Strahan and Osi Umenyiora. The Giants aren't the NFL's best team, but they weren't last year either. If they can get hot again at the right time, lightning could strike twice.
The Problem: Eli Manning still isn't trustworthy and can look great one moment and then terrible a few minutes later. The defence is not as dominant without Umenyiora and Strahan.
5. Chicago Bears
Yes, I'm aware that I left the Eagles, Vikings, Bucs and Panthers off of my list of contenders, but I think the Bears could continue to surprise this season. Kyle Orton has impressed me in two big wins for the Bears and Chicago's offensive line looks good. So far, the Bears schedule has looked like this: at Indianapolis, at Carolina, Tampa Bay, and Philadelphia. Those four teams have a combined record of 9-5 and both games Chicago lost were by a field goal. If the Bears defence can stay healthy, Chicago could challenge now that they finally seem to have a good quarterback.
The Problem: The Bears are 2-2 and have lost two close games. They need to figure out how to win those close ones, especially when they're at home. They also need to keep their defence healthy and if Orton can consistently have good games, they could end up being a legitimate Super Bowl contender.
**Stay tuned for my Week 5 picks ATS later on this week. I've had two terrible weeks in a row, but I'm going to guarantee .500 or better this week!